What a good recruitment brief looks like
Most recruitment briefs I receive are wishlists in disguise.
They are not wrong, exactly. They are just too optimistic to be useful. Twelve years in luxury. LVMH background preferred. Fluent in clienteling. Strong on AI. Culturally literate. Available next month. Comfortable in the £180K–£220K range. Reader, that person exists in approximately three living humans, and none of them are moving for the compensation on offer.
The reason this matters is that a shortlist is only ever as sharp as the brief. A vague brief produces a safe shortlist, which produces a safe hire, which is how houses end up culturally invisible five years later. A precise, honest brief produces the opposite outcome. It is, without exaggeration, the single most important document in the entire process — and it is almost always the one the client has spent the least amount of time on.
What a good brief actually contains:
- The two non-negotiables, named specifically. Not seven. Two. If brand instinct and commercial discipline are the qualities you cannot compromise on, say so. The other five are teachable, transferable, or hireable underneath. The brief that flexes on everything gets no candidates. The brief that flexes on nothing gets the wrong ones.
- The honest read on the inflection point. Is this a growth hire, a fix hire, a succession hire, or a repositioning hire? The four require completely different candidates. Most briefs do not name which one this is, which is why most first shortlists land wrong.
- What the last person got right, and what they got wrong. Genuinely the most useful data any brief can carry. It signals to the recruiter what the real risks are, and it signals to the candidate what they are actually walking into. Sanitised versions of this are worse than useless.
- A realistic compensation range, benchmarked to now. Not to the last time you hired this role. Not to what the finance team would like it to be. What the market will actually pay for the profile you have just described. Getting this wrong is how six-month searches happen.
- A named decision-maker, and an honest timeline. Who signs off. Who has veto. When the role actually needs to be filled. And, candidly, what happens if it drifts by a month, a quarter, six months. Briefs that leave this vague tend to become the searches that never quite close.
What unites all of that is a single principle. A good brief has already made the difficult decisions. It has already had the internal argument about trade-offs, about compensation, about non-negotiables, about timeline. The hard conversation has happened, at the front, in the room where it belongs — not in month four of the search, when the recruiter is trying to explain why the shortlist hasn’t landed.
The brief is not the paperwork before the work. The brief is the work. Get it right, and the rest of the process tends to look after itself.
Charlie
Founder, Jackson Rose Recruitment
www.jacksonrose.co.uk



