Luxury Insights

Strict parents make sneaky kids. Strict companies make sneaky staff.


By Charlie Jackson

A dark wood door standing slightly open, with warm lamplight spilling onto a herringbone floor from a formal navy and burgundy hallway.

My 16-year-old daughter said this to me last week, mid-eye-roll, about a friend with a curfew of “before it gets dark.” She wasn’t talking about HR policy, but it got me thinking. I’ve been in enough briefing calls with luxury brands wondering why their best marketing hire just handed in their notice “out of nowhere” to know exactly what she meant.

Rules built on control rather than trust don’t stop the behaviour you’re worried about. They just move it somewhere you can’t see it. Ban the sleepover, you get the sneaking out the window. Clock everyone in at 9am with a badge scanner and a raised eyebrow if anyone’s WFH twice a month, and you don’t get more commitment. You get better liars.

Exhibit A: coffee badging — swiping into the office, being seen, having a coffee, and quietly leaving within the hour. Fifty-eight percent of hybrid workers admit to it, per Owl Labs’ State of Hybrid Work research. That’s not a fringe behaviour, that’s a majority coping mechanism for a rule nobody thinks is worth actually following.

And the people best at this particular art form, in my world, are marketing and PR people. Which makes sense — their entire job is managing a narrative and making an exit look more graceful than it is. You will not out-manoeuvre a comms director on optics.

The research backs it up. A Baylor University study of 54 large firms found abnormal turnover jumped 13–14% after return-to-office mandates, and it wasn’t the average performer leaving. Senior managers and highly skilled staff left faster than junior colleagues, and female employees left at nearly three times the rate of male ones. Vacancies took 23% longer to fill afterwards. The mandate meant to boost “culture” quietly hollowed out the people the business could least afford to lose.

That’s the trap. The clampdown doesn’t produce compliance — it produces staff who smile in the Monday meeting while their CV, references and notice period are already sorted. Nobody wants a scene. They just leave, tidily and professionally, usually to a competitor who worked out that flexibility isn’t a perk, it’s a filter for who trusts you enough to stay.

A few tells for any luxury brand that’s tightened the reins and now wonders why the senior marketing bench looks thinner:

  • Calls taken “outside” more often, and a curious rise in dentist appointments.
  • Everything looks fine — attendance, engagement scores — and that’s usually the tell.
  • LinkedIn activity has quietly picked up. Not posting. Liking. Connecting with recruiters.

Good parents have boundaries; so do good employers. The question is whether the rule builds trust or just proves you don’t have any. One gets you a kid who tells you where they’re actually going. The other gets a very convincing story about a sleepover.

If you’re a luxury brand rethinking how tightly to hold the reins on marketing and comms — or a candidate already halfway out the window who’d rather do it properly — that’s a conversation I have every day. Happy to have it with you too.

Charlie, Founder, Jackson Rose Recruitment

For what it’s worth, my daughter thinks we’re quite relaxed parents compared to some of her friends 😊

← All Luxury Insights